Specializing in custom cakes, wedding cakes, and unique desserts, made with love in McAlester, Oklahoma.
Welcome to Cottage Sweets Baking Co., where every treat is made with love in our home kitchen in rural Southeast Oklahoma. I'm Sarah, a former elementary teacher who discovered my passion for baking while staying home with my daughter.
Our family—my husband, our beautiful little girl, and our two playful dogs—loves spending time together outdoors on our land. This connection to nature and family values is reflected in everything we bake.
As a self-taught baker, I take pride in creating elevated, delicious desserts that bring joy to any occasion. Whether you're celebrating a special event or simply treating yourself, each creation is made with the same care and attention to detail that I bring to my family.
At Cottage Sweets Baking Co., we specialize in bringing your sweet visions to life! From beautifully decorated custom cakes for birthdays and special events to intricate wedding cakes and unique handcrafted treats like custom cookies, bars, and cupcakes, every item is made to order with the highest quality ingredients and meticulous attention to detail. Share your ideas with us, and let's create something unforgettable for your next celebration.
Sarah does an AMAZING job creating the perfect designs of whatever you have in mind! They are absolutely delicious. I could not recommend someone more to make your sweet treats for whatever you may be celebrating!
- Abby English
The absolute best! Not only with taste but the detail! Sarah also offers dye free which is so nice! Sarah is the best! Use her for all your baking needs!!!!
- Rachel Oldham
Sarah did a beautiful and most importantly tasty job on two recent cakes of ours. We specifically asked for no food dyes...
- Madison Brock
Sarah's work is beautiful, but it tastes like it was made specially for you with love by your mom! Absolutely delicious. I love her inclusive options, making them perfect for any occasion! You've got to give Cottage Sweets a try!
- Jessie Matthews
Yes, absolutely! We specialize in creating beautiful and delicious custom cakes for all occasions, including elegant wedding cakes, birthdays, anniversaries, and more. Contact us to discuss your vision!
We recommend placing custom orders as early as possible, especially for larger events like weddings, to ensure availability. For smaller custom orders, at least 1-2 weeks notice is generally appreciated, but feel free to inquire even for last-minute requests!
Yes! We understand the need for dietary considerations and are happy to offer dye-free options for many of our treats. Please specify your needs when placing your order.
We are a home-based bakery located in rural Southeast Oklahoma, serving the McAlester area. Our hours for order pick-ups and consultations are typically Monday-Friday, 8AM-5PM, but this can be flexible by appointment.
You can get in touch with us through the contact form on our website, by phone at (918) 916-9988, or by sending us a message with details about your desired treats, date, and any inspiration photos you have. We'll get back to you promptly!